Rational suicide

Rational suicide is the reason-guided decision to end one's life, specifically, when these reasons are the result of an indifferent or temperate weighing of pros and cons. It has been argued that a suicide can be rational and still nonetheless be a mistake.[1] Rational suicide is sometimes viewed as a subjective concept; Jerome Motto writes, "What may be an inconvenience, a source of discomfort, or an embarrassment to one person represents unbearable agony, excruciating pain, or intolerable humiliation to another."[2] One study of mental health counselors found that 80% of respondents were moderately supportive of the idea that people can make well-reasoned decisions that death is their best option.[3] It is believed that in coming years clinicians will increasingly be confronted by patients declaring their intention to exercise their right-to-suicide or to commit what they describe as a rational suicide.[4] The “received orthodoxy” of mental health professionals for more than a century views all suicides as irrational and holds that suicidal persons should always be prevented from ending their own lives.[5]

See also

References

  1. ^ A Pilpel, L Amsel, What is Wrong with Rational Suicide, http://www.avitalpilpel.com/uploads/What_is_wrong_with_rational_suicide_April_2010.pdf 
  2. ^ James L. Werth, Rational suicide?: implications for mental health professionals 
  3. ^ Rational Suicide: An Empirical Investigation of Counselor Attitudes, 79, Journal of Counseling & Development, Summer 2001, pp. 365–372, http://aca.metapress.com/index/HNUE6LUPB5GKDNYC.pdf 
  4. ^ Siegel, Karolynn (June, 1982), "Rational suicide: Considerations for the clinician", Psychiatric Quarterly (Psychiatric Quarterly) 54 (2): 77–84, doi:10.1007/BF01064749, ISSN 1573-6709, PMID 7146216 
  5. ^ DJ Mayo (1998), "Rational suicide?", Journal of Loss and Trauma (Journal of Loss and Trauma) 3 (2): 193–203, doi:10.1080/10811449808414441